Manta Rays Under Attack – Will CITES Save the Manta

Will the killing stop before it is too late?

Warning: This journal contains disturbing imagery and narrative.

In the past 3 years I have traveled to the corners of the planet, to some of the most remote and inaccessible coastal regions, to document the unchecked and often secret slaughter of one of the most graceful, charismatic, gentle and vulnerable of marine species…the Manta Ray. Several years ago I teamed up with my good friend and uncompromising conservation photographer Paul Hilton, to expose this senseless destruction and to try to put an end to it.

This mission took us on an unforgettable journey,  one that exposed us to constant danger, threat of violence, brutal conditions, exhaustion and incredible frustration. But what we were not prepared for  was the extent and brutality of the manta fisheries, and how the shark fin trader network had become the driving force behind this exploitation. What we witnessed tore at our hearts, blackened our souls, and all but crushed what hope remained within us.

Steel spearhead fashioned from car spring ready to kill

Fishermen spot and chase down manta ray

Fisherman launches of bow to spear manta ray

Spearhead lodges in manta with fisherman’s weight driving it in

 

I cannot erase  from my mind the images of the fisherman driving a barbed steel spearhead into the back of a fleeing giant manta ray, followed by the hour of struggle as the terribly wounded creature fought for it’s life…twisting and rolling in anguish, helplessly pulling against a thick rope held taught in the muscular arms of experienced fishermen. And then, that moment, when the exhausted manta ray was pulled up along side the boat and our eyes connected. In that instant when I looked into its deep dark eye, I saw desperation, fear and confusion…the look of an innocent small child that has suffered a traumatic injury. The manta reached out to me as I had seen mantas do before underwater when I had interacted with them for hours on the vibrant reefs of Misool in Raja Ampat…but this time it was a desperate plea for help…and I was powerless to do anything. My heart raced and my mind spun. Next the fishermen sliced a hole in the head of the struggling manta using the sharp blade of long butcher knife. I struggled to control my emotions as this grizzly scene unfolded; but what happened next pushed me to the edge. The fisherman grabbed a rusty iron rod, and leaning over the edge of the boat, plunged the rod into the brain of the manta. Every muscle in the manta’s body instantly spasmed, then slowly relaxed. With my face just one meter from the mantas eye, I watched as the final breath of life drained from its limp body…and in that final moment I saw a look of forgiveness and sorrow, sorrow for the senseless waste, the barbaric and brutal actions of humans, and the loss of yet another member of this vanishing species of gentle giants.

Manta struggles for its life

Fisherman uses sharp knife to cut hole in mantas head

Fisherman plunges rusty steel wire into mantas brain

 

My breath escaped me. I was screaming yet no sounds were heard. My soul wept yet no tears fell to the water. Using all my willpower, I fought back my emotions, my feelings of intense rage and sorrow, and buried them in a dark conner of my soul, a place I call the Dark Room. For in this remote community of ritual hunters, to reveal even the slightest contempt for this hunt was to potentially place my life and that of my teammates in jeopardy. So I forced a smile and turned away as the hunt continued. It took 5 strong men to pull the 5 meter manta on board . They then sliced its wings off and stacked the bloody carcass in the boat. As we motored  back to the village, a fleet of diesel powered boats streamed past us and out to sea. Word had spread quickly over the cell phone network that a family of mantas had arrived. Armed with sharpened steel spearheads, these hunters were determined to speer and kill every manta they could.

Lifeless manta suspended from fishing boat

Fishermen with manta stretched across bow

Fishermen cut up manta ray

 

When we neared the shoreline, the massive body parts of the manta were dumped into the shallows and dragged ashore. There, a cheering mob towed them onto the beach and began chopping with machetes. The gills were cut out first, carefully cleaned and placed in bags and buckets. Select portions of meat were cut into strips, tied into rings and hung on bamboo racks to dry in the sun. The rest of the manta, including its head, was discarded in the waves washing on the beach.

Crowd drags manta body up on beach

Village woman holds gills cut from manta

Woman hold the head of a huge manta ray

 

We stood on the beach in heat of the afternoon sun, praying that the rest of the manta family had escaped this cruel fate…but that was not to be. A boat pulled into the bay with the bodies of two giant mantas draped across the haul. These too were dumped into the water and dragged ashore, The crowed cheered and the energy intensified as they set upon the dead mantas with knives. More boats appeared and more mantas were pulled to the beach to be butchered. The beach sand was saturated with blood as the bodies of 15 giant mantas were cut to pieces. And when we thought the situation could not get any worse, it turned into a nightmare. We watched as an unborn baby manta only 1 meter in width was cut from the womb of it’s lifeless mother, a giant and ancient female over 6 meters across. The children of the village tossed the baby around like a play toy, cheering and jostling in excitement. When they were done, they dumped it on the beach where it was consumed by the waves. We had seen enough!

Woman holds gills from butchered manta

Fisherman stands over remains of several manta rays

Baby manta draped across its dead mother

Village children hold dead baby manta

 

What was once a small-scale, opportunistic artisanal hunt had transformed into an all-out  commercial fishery intent on capturing every last manta ray. And why?  For their gills. We followed the buckets of gills as they were carried up to a traders house. Here they were weighted then laid out on concrete to dry in the sun. We learned that the gills from a manta ray earn these traders USD100 per kilo. A medium manta ray can produce 5 kilos of dried gills and a large manta ray, 7 kilos…up to USD700 for a single manta ray. That is a LOT of money in a remote fishing village. On the other hand, the meat was sold locally for less than USD 40. A decade ago, Chinese shark fin traders had established trade relations with this community, helping supply diesel engines and gear to increase their manta landings.

Buyers wife stands over bucket of gills before weighing

Buyer lays out gills in sun to dry

 

The gills  are transported through traditional shark fin trade routes to China, Singapore and Hong Kong. But why are certain Asian communities so interested in Gills? It turns out that shark fin traders, in a move to offset diminishing profits due to scarcity of large shark fins because of overexploitation, had revived an relatively obscure, psuedo-medicinal coastal remedy call Peng Yu Sai. Peng Yu Sai is a soup consisting of boiled manta gills, seahorses and pipefish that is prescribed to treat fevers, chickenpox, and heat in the body. I call this “endangered species soup”. The traders then began marketing this remedy as Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) and a niche industry was born. It is worth noting that our interviews with TCM practitioners revealed that Peng Yu Sai was in fact not considered a part of TCM.

Bowl of Peng Yu Sai

Ingrediants for Peng Yu Sai

Trader holds gill of manta ray for sale

 

It was immediately apparent that the situation was out of control and needed serious attention. WildAid and Shark Savers joined as founding partners of our new project called Manta Ray of Hope. The project is a joint initiative that includes top field investigators and leading scientists and researches, all working together to further the conservation of manta and mobula rays. Mary O’Malley joined the team as project co-lead, adding one of the most committed, selfless, competent and effective forces in shark and ray conservation. Hannah Med also joined, adding critical research and writing skills to the team. Together we set out on a mission to expose the destruction of manta and mobula rays and put an end to the slaughter.

As a first step, we created a short documentary called Manta Ray of Hope that brought this issue to the attention of world, . But awareness is not enough, and we had to gather the hard facts needed to tackle fishers and trade regulations.  Our next mission was to create the most comprehensive report ever completed on global state of manta and mobula rays. Over the course of 2 years, we conducted 10 primary studies on manta and mobula fisheries, markets, and tourism destinations. We also scoured every scientific paper, fishery study, government report and news article on manta and mobula ray from around the world. Our partners The Manta Trust, Marine Megafauna Foundation, Equilibrio Azul, Planeta Oceano, and others provided critical research, unpublished findings and guidance to help complete our study. Further, an impressive team of Advisors, comprising the leaders in manta and mobula research from around the world, reviewed, edited and signed off on the report. And lastly, our partners John Weller and Cassandra Brooks played an instrumental role in final drafting and preparation of the report. In January of 2012 WildAid and Shark Savers released the final report, Manta Ray of Hope – The Global Threat To Manta and Mobula Rays.

Since the release of the report, our team has focused on using the findings presented in the report to achieve true conservation outcomes. As a first step, our focus has been on securing international protection for manta rays. In November of 2011, we assisted the Ecuador delegation on their successful proposal to list Manta birostris (Oceanic Manta Ray) under the Convention on Migratory Species (CMS). Though an important first step, CMS is not a binding treaty and thereby nations are not obligated to abide by the treaty provisions.

The Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES), is the only international  treaty established to protect endangered species that is considered binding on member nations. The body, now consisting of 176 member nations, generally meets once every 3 years to vote on species to be protected. The selection process is rigorous and highly political,  and of the many deserving species, only a select few survive the process and achieve listing status. The next meeting will be held in Bangkok in March of 2013.

Today Ecuador continues to establish itself as global leader in the conservation of manta rays. Together with Brazil and Columbia, they submitted the official proposal for manta rays to be considered for Appendix II listing by the CITES Secretariat at the CoP16 meeting. Our team is delighted  and honored to have contributed research and been involved the process, and it is our greatest hope that members nations of CITES will vote in favor of protecting manta rays!

Manta ray glides through open ocean

Time is running out for manta rays. Long lived (50 years or more), slow to mature (8-10 years or more), and very slow to reproduce (1 pup every 2-3 years), manta rays are some of the most biologically vulnerable of any large marine species. A female manta may give birth to 16 pups over her entire lifetime, IF she is not slaughtered. To put that in perspective, the highly vulnerable great white shark can produce that many pups in a single litter. Yet manta rays are being hunted relentlessly across the globe, a slaughter fueled primarily by demand for their gills. At current rates, many manta populations will be lost within the next decade. The question is, will the wold take notices and will we ACT before it is too late? And finally, when I close my eyes at night, will the nightmares of the manta slaughter finally be put to rest?

Mobula rays pass below, as if drifting through the stars of outer space

 

Please support the work to protect manta and mobula rays:

MantaRayOfHope.org

WildAid.org

SharkSavers.org

The Manta Trust

 

Additional Media:

Manta Fisheries

Gill Raker Trade

 

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

18 Responses to “Manta Rays Under Attack – Will CITES Save the Manta”

  1. Epi llamanzares October 5, 2012 at 2:59 am // Reply

    poor creature. :(( where were the pictures taken? :(

    #

  2. Gary Stokes October 5, 2012 at 3:51 am // Reply

    Excellent story Shawn. Even though I have known of this through Paul and what I have seen, this is shocking yet incredible imagery. Here’s to hoping some sanity returns to CITES in Bangkok next year. We’ve had some good progress with the Dr Giam case and conflict of interest is back on the agenda for a vote early march, before CoP 16.

    #

  3. Susan Bruce October 5, 2012 at 11:33 am // Reply

    Reading this made me nauseous.
    Thanks Shawn for doing such a great, in-depth story that also connects us with concrete measures for protection. The poor fishermen don’t see the big picture. And how do you provide alternatives to $100/kilo? Got to work at all levels of the chain from supply to demand.

    #

  4. Ms Mermaid October 5, 2012 at 7:39 pm // Reply

    This story made me so sad!

    #

  5. Udo van Dongen October 9, 2012 at 6:29 am // Reply

    Heartbreaking story, hopefully this will stop before the last big manta is destroyed. Was this at whalehunter’s village Lamalera, Indonesia? We were there last year and fortunately we didn’t see any big fish, because most likely we then would have witnessed this kind of slaughter too.

    #

  6. Evelyn Jeanne Shaw October 11, 2012 at 8:01 am // Reply

    I’ve read some good stuff here. Definitely worth bookmarking for revisiting.

    #

  7. classic ugg styles October 13, 2012 at 4:00 am // Reply

    Enjoyed every bit of your article post.Much thanks again. Cool.

    #

  8. jordan 3 true blue October 15, 2012 at 11:09 pm // Reply

    Muchos Gracias for your article.Really thank you! Much obliged.

    #

  9. Terry bull October 17, 2012 at 11:42 am // Reply

    Great work Shawn , we need CITES , first to address the conflict of issues farce , then to actually do the job we all hoped they would …

    #

  10. Makeup tips October 19, 2012 at 9:12 am // Reply

    Awesome post, where is the rss? I cant find it!

    #

  11. Darryl January 2, 2013 at 8:47 pm // Reply

    This is shocking. Many thanks for bringing this to my (and many others) attention. As a keen scuba diver living in SE Asia I know what a draw mantas are to divers. Over their lifespan they would be worth far more alive as a major draw for a dive location than they are dead. They need to have an economic value to the locals as living animals which exceeds that of them dead. That needs to be part of any strategy to try to protect them as it will take a long time to change Chinese habits (if at all) and there will always be a black market even if trade is banned.
    Let’s hope something can be done quickly to stop this utterly pointless and wasteful slaughter.

    #

  12. Peter Y May 4, 2013 at 6:22 am // Reply

    Coming from Hong Kong, it’s shameful that so many people still eat shark fin and believe in garbage about the nutritional value of exotic foods. It’s been hundreds of years since the scientific revolution and selfish people here still consume.

    These beliefs will take time to change (see how little Food Inc has done to change American habits on meat production) but there’s still a little hope because many Chinese celebrities and average people like myself have begun to speak out about unsustainable fishing and hundred year old practices that need to change.

    #

  13. Phuket travel June 8, 2013 at 6:44 pm // Reply

    Good web site you have here.. It’s hard to find good quality writing like yours these days. I honestly appreciate people like you! Take care!!

    #

  14. Accommodation In Phuket June 9, 2013 at 6:45 am // Reply

    Good info. Lucky me I found your blog by chance (stumbleupon).

    I’ve book-marked it for later!

    #

  15. phuket hotels resorts Accommodation June 9, 2013 at 6:45 am // Reply

    I blog often and I seriously appreciate your information.
    This article has really peaked my interest. I am going to
    book mark your site and keep checking for new information about
    once per week. I subscribed to your Feed as well.

    #

  16. Island in Thailand June 13, 2013 at 1:48 pm // Reply

    Hello! I’ve been reading your web site for a while now and finally got the bravery to go ahead and give you a shout out from Dallas Tx! Just wanted to say keep up the great work!

    #

  17. HearthStone Beta Keys October 18, 2013 at 1:27 pm // Reply

    Thanks for a marvelous posting! I genuinely enjoyed readjng it,
    you will be a great author. I will be sure too bookmark your blog and may come back from now on.
    I want to encourage yourself to continue your great job, have a nice holiday weekend!

    #

  18. tips for writing a novel November 19, 2013 at 11:21 am // Reply

    Good blog post. I absolutely love this site. Keep writing!

    #

Leave a Reply